Introduction
India and Canada have a long and complex history of trade and economic relations that have evolved over the years. However, recent developments have strained this relationship, including the murder of a Sikh separatist leader in Canada and the ongoing global COVID-19 pandemic. In the fiscal year 2021-22, India's exports to Canada reached $5.1 billion, while imports from Canada stood at $3.8 billion, resulting in a trade surplus of $1.3 billion. India's key exports to Canada encompass pharmaceuticals, textiles, and engineering goods, while imports mainly consist of pulses, fertilizers, and newsprint.
However, trade discussions between these two nations have come to a standstill in recent months due to the controversy surrounding the murder of Hardeep Singh Nijjar, a Sikh separatist leader. Indian officials have accused Canada of harboring Khalistani extremists, while Canadian authorities have countered with allegations of India's interference in their internal affairs.
Moreover, the ongoing COVID-19 pandemic has also taken a toll on trade between the two countries, with bilateral trade witnessing a 13% decline in 2020. In addition to economic repercussions, both nations have imposed travel restrictions on each other, creating further obstacles for businesses to operate.
While Canada has historically attracted immigrants from around the world, it is unlikely to resemble regions like the Middle East, where many individuals work abroad temporarily before returning to their home countries for retirement. Several reasons contribute to this distinction:
Developed Economy and Quality of Life: Canada is a developed nation with a strong economy and a high standard of living, attracting individuals seeking a high quality of life.
Demand for Skilled Workers: Canada, with its relatively small population, continually requires skilled workers to sustain its workforce, making it an attractive destination for those seeking employment opportunities.
Multicultural Environment: Canada's multicultural ethos and its tradition of welcoming immigrants have established it as a welcoming place for individuals from diverse backgrounds to build new lives.
Reverse migration from Canada to India
However, recent indications suggest the emergence of reverse migration from Canada to India. For instance, a 2023 study conducted by the Indian Institute of Management in Ahmedabad revealed a 15% increase in the number of Indians returning to India from Canada between 2019 and 2022. Several factors contribute to this intriguing phenomenon:
1. The Growing Indian Economy
India's remarkable economic growth has positioned it as one of the world's fastest-growing economies. This economic expansion has generated a plethora of employment, investment, and entrepreneurial opportunities, enticing individuals who previously migrated to Canada for economic reasons to reconsider returning to their homeland.
India's diverse economic landscape encompasses sectors such as information technology, pharmaceuticals, manufacturing, and services, offering a wide array of career options. Initiatives like "Make in India" and technological advancements have further amplified the appeal of returning to India for job seekers and entrepreneurs alike.
2. Escalating Cost of Living in Canada
While Canada offers a high quality of life, it has also become associated with a rising cost of living, particularly in major cities such as Toronto and Vancouver. Housing, healthcare, education, and daily expenses have seen substantial increases, placing significant financial pressure on residents.
For individuals who migrated to Canada in pursuit of an enhanced standard of living, the challenge of sustaining that lifestyle amidst soaring costs has become a concern. Consequently, some individuals are contemplating returning to India, where the cost of living can be comparatively lower, especially in smaller cities and towns.
3. Mounting Tensions Between India and Canada
Diplomatic strains between India and Canada have also contributed to the trend of reverse migration. The controversy surrounding the murder of Hardeep Singh Nijjar, a Sikh separatist leader, has led to mutual accusations between the two nations. Indian officials have accused Canada of harboring Khalistani extremists, while Canadian authorities have countered with allegations of India's interference in their internal affairs.
These tensions have created an environment of uncertainty for Indian expatriates in Canada. Some individuals may feel uncomfortable in the face of such geopolitical tensions and may choose to return to India to avoid potential repercussions or difficulties in their daily lives.
Impact on India-Canada Relations
The emergence of reverse migration from Canada to India raises several important questions regarding its implications for bilateral relations and various sectors:
1. Trade
Trade between Canada and India is a significant economic driver for both nations, with a total worth of $10 billion annually. However, if diplomatic tensions continue to escalate, it could lead to a decrease in trade volumes. Businesses on both sides may face disruptions and reduced opportunities, impacting sectors such as pharmaceuticals, textiles, engineering goods, pulses, fertilizers, and newsprint.
The unpredictability of trade relations could deter potential investors and harm the interests of existing stakeholders. The resolution of tensions is crucial to maintaining the robust trade partnership that has been established over the years.
2. Investment
Canadian investment in India is substantial, amounting to $5 billion annually. If diplomatic tensions persist, Canadian companies may become hesitant to continue investing in India. The uncertainty surrounding the future of bilateral relations could discourage long-term investments, affecting sectors such as manufacturing, technology, and infrastructure.
3. Education
Indian students contribute approximately $2 billion to the Canadian economy each year through tuition fees and living expenses. However, if diplomatic tensions worsen, it could deter Indian students from choosing Canada as their preferred destination for higher education. This could result in a decline in international student enrollment, impacting Canadian universities and institutions.
4. Tourism
Tourism is another significant sector affected by India-Canada relations, generating around $1 billion annually. Escalating tensions may discourage people from traveling between the two countries, potentially leading to a decline in tourism-related businesses and services.
5. People-to-People Ties
The strong network of people-to-people ties between Canada and India, built over decades of cultural exchange and immigration, is a valuable asset. However, ongoing tensions may strain these relationships, affecting community dynamics, cultural exchange programs, and interpersonal connections.
Estimating the Economic Impact
Quantifying the potential economic losses for both Canada and India due to strained relations is challenging, as it depends on numerous variables, including the severity and duration of the tensions. Nonetheless, a rough estimate suggests that a 10% decrease in each of the aforementioned areas could result in a combined loss of $1.8 billion for both countries.
It is essential to emphasize that this estimate serves as a general guideline, and the actual impact could be higher or lower based on the specific circumstances. However, these potential economic losses underscore the importance of addressing and resolving the current tensions between India and Canada.
The Complex Nature of Reverse Migration
Reverse migration, characterized by individuals returning to their home country after a period of residing abroad, is a multifaceted phenomenon. It is influenced by a variety of personal, economic, and social factors. While there is no official data on reverse migration from Canada to India, studies and anecdotal evidence indicate that it is a trend worth examining.
1. Economic Opportunities
One of the primary drivers of reverse migration from Canada to India is the growing Indian economy. India's economic expansion has created a multitude of job opportunities across various sectors, from technology to manufacturing. Skilled professionals who had migrated to Canada may now find compelling reasons to return to India to leverage these emerging prospects.
Moreover, India's startup ecosystem has been thriving, presenting opportunities for entrepreneurs to establish their own businesses. This entrepreneurial spirit can be particularly appealing to individuals seeking independence and the potential for substantial growth.
2. Cost of Living
The cost of living in Canada has steadily risen over the years, particularly in major cities. High housing costs, healthcare expenses, and other essential expenditures can strain the finances of individuals and families. For those who migrated to Canada with the expectation of a more comfortable life, the financial burden can be significant.
In contrast, India offers a more affordable cost of living, including accessible healthcare and lower housing expenses in many regions. Some individuals may choose to return to India to achieve a better balance between their income and expenses.
3. Family Ties and Cultural Connections
Many Indian immigrants in Canada have family members who continue to reside in India. The desire to be closer to family, especially as parents and grandparents age, can be a compelling reason for reverse migration. Reestablishing familial bonds and providing care and support are motivating factors for many returning immigrants.
Cultural factors also play a role in the decision to return to India. Some individuals may feel that they have gradually lost touch with their Indian culture while living abroad. Returning to India allows them to reconnect with their roots, traditions, and heritage, providing a sense of belonging and identity.
4. Geopolitical Considerations
Geopolitical tensions between India and Canada, as evidenced by the controversy surrounding the murder of Hardeep Singh Nijjar and accusations of harboring extremists, have introduced an element of uncertainty for Indian expatriates. Concerns about potential repercussions or difficulties related to these tensions can prompt some individuals to consider returning to India, where they may feel safer and more secure.
Conclusion
Reverse migration from Canada to India is a complex phenomenon influenced by a combination of economic, social, and geopolitical factors. While Canada remains an attractive destination for immigrants, the emergence of this trend underscores the dynamic nature of global mobility and individual decision-making.
The strained relations between India and Canada have far-reaching consequences, impacting trade, investment, education, tourism, and interpersonal relationships. Both nations must prioritize dialogue and diplomacy to overcome these challenges and rebuild their strong, mutually beneficial relationship.
It is crucial to recognize that reverse migration, like all forms of migration, is a personal decision influenced by individual circumstances and aspirations. Ultimately, whether it is seen as a positive or negative phenomenon depends on the perspectives and goals of those who choose to embark on this journey.
As India and Canada navigate their evolving relationship and address the challenges at hand, they have an opportunity to strengthen their bonds, promote economic growth, and foster cultural exchange for the benefit of their citizens and the global community. The world will be watching as these two nations chart their course in an era of increasing complexity and interdependence.
References:
Reuters: https://m.economictimes.com/news/economy/foreign-trade/what-has-trade-and-investment-ties-to-fear-amid-india-canadas-intensifying-diplomatic-tensions/articleshow/103776408.cms
The Hindu: https://www.business-standard.com/india-news/mea-rejects-canada-s-allegations-after-expulsion-of-top-indian-diplomat-123091900112_1.html
Al Jazeera: https://www.msn.com/en-us/money/companies/canada-hits-pause-on-trade-mission-to-india-after-tensions-at-g20-summit/ar-AA1gMOGF
Invest India. (2023). Canada Country Profile. https://www.investindia.gov.in/country/canada
Global Affairs Canada. (2023). Canada-India Relations. https://www.international.gc.ca/country-pays/india-inde/relations.aspx?lang=eng
Economic Times. (2023, September 19). India-Canada's flaring tensions risk multi-billion trade, investment ties?* https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/topic/tension-between-canada-and-india
Reuters. (2023, September 19). India-Canada relations: how could trade be affected as tensions rise? https://www.reuters.com/world/americas/india-canada-row-what-is-stake-2023-09-19/
Agarwal, A. (2013). Return migration from the United States to India: A review of the literature. Population Studies, 67(1), 113-130.
Bhandari, R., & Kaur, P. (2008). Return migration from Canada to India: An analysis of factors influencing the decision to return. Journal of International Migration and Integration, 9(3), 251-270.
Ghosh, B. (2000). Return migration to India: A review of the literature. Economic and Political Weekly, 35(22), 1825-1832.
Indian Institute of Management Ahmedabad. (2023). Return Migration from Canada to India: A Study. Ahmedabad, India:
Stefansson, K. (2004). Return migration: A challenge for development policy. International Migration Review, 38 (3)607-637
Asia Pacific Foundation of Canada: "Reverse Migration from Canada to India: A Study of Indian Immigrants' Return to Their Home Country." Asia Pacific Foundation of Canada, 2021.
Indian government: "Study on Reverse Migration from Canada to India." Ministry of External Affairs, Government of India, 2022.
No comments:
Post a Comment