Clusterkraft
Catalyzing Change: Exploring Local and Global Socio-Economic Development
Tuesday, April 1, 2025
India vs China: A Tale of Two Startup Worlds
Tuesday, March 25, 2025
Entrepreneurial Strategies for Emerging Economies
Thursday, March 20, 2025
Vertical Integration vs. Cluster-Based Specialization: Finding the Right Economic Balance
India’s Missed Priorities: A Critical Look at Education, Infrastructure, and Economic Strategy
The Fear of Educated Unemployment: A Political and Social Dilemma
One of the surprising narratives from those early years was the fear surrounding educated unemployment. Leaders hesitated to aggressively push education, worrying that creating a large pool of educated youth without corresponding job opportunities would lead to social and political unrest. This concern, though understandable given the limited industrial base and employment opportunities at the time, proved short-sighted. Today, we understand that education doesn't just create job seekers — it creates innovators and entrepreneurs who, in turn, generate employment for others.
Higher Education: A Partial Success Story
It’s important to acknowledge that India did not neglect higher education. The establishment of institutions like the Indian Institutes of Technology (IITs) and the Indian Institutes of Management (IIMs) laid the foundation for India’s success in the global IT and managerial landscape. The results are visible in India’s rise as a global technology powerhouse. However, this focus on higher education was not matched by similar attention to primary and secondary education. According to World Bank data, even today, India struggles with literacy rates and learning outcomes that lag behind many developing nations. This has created a situation where only a small fraction reaches the heights of technical education, while a large segment remains under-educated and under-skilled.
Infrastructure: A Comparison with China
India’s infrastructure story post-independence is one of lost opportunities. At the time of independence, India’s railways were more developed than China’s. Fast forward to today, and the contrast is stark. China has built the fastest and most expansive railway network in the world, including high-speed rail lines that have transformed connectivity and logistics. Meanwhile, India’s rail network, though vast, struggles with congestion, delays, and outdated technology.
Freight transport in India heavily relies on roadways, which is inefficient and expensive. According to the Ministry of Road Transport and Highways, road transport carries around 65% of India’s freight, despite railway freight being cheaper and more environmentally friendly. The shift away from rail freight has not only increased logistics costs but also added to traffic congestion and environmental pollution.
The Role of Airports: A New Realization
Only recently has India begun recognizing the potential of developing regional airports. The government’s UDAN (Ude Desh ka Aam Nagrik) scheme has targeted smaller towns and regional connectivity, aiming to make air travel accessible to common citizens. This is a significant shift from past decades, where airports were confined to major cities. While 40,000 airports may be a distant dream, the current expansion in smaller towns is a step in the right direction. However, the impact of air travel on mass freight movement remains limited, and thus cannot compensate for inadequate railway and road infrastructure.
Critical Reflection: What Could Have Been Done Differently?
The early post-independence strategy of "grow first, distribute later" may have worked in parts, but it failed to create an inclusive and sustainable foundation. Three critical lessons emerge:
-
Education for All, Not Just the Elite: A more balanced approach to primary, secondary, and higher education could have created a more skilled workforce at every level, reducing unemployment and underemployment and creating a more robust domestic demand base.
-
Infrastructure as an Economic Enabler: Investment in railways, roads, and later, regional airports should have been prioritized as part of the core growth strategy, not as an afterthought. The ability to move goods and people efficiently is fundamental to economic competitiveness.
-
Long-term Vision Over Immediate Fears: Fear of educated unemployment, while understandable, curtailed the country’s ability to harness its demographic dividend. A confident, visionary policy could have instead encouraged mass education with complementary industrial and entrepreneurial development.
The Way Forward
India now stands at a juncture where these lessons are increasingly acknowledged. Investments in education have improved, with programs like Samagra Shiksha aiming to integrate school education from pre-school to Class 12. The Gati Shakti program focuses on integrated infrastructure planning, and railway modernization is gaining momentum with initiatives like dedicated freight corridors.
However, India needs to ensure these efforts are not fragmented but part of a cohesive vision. The opportunity cost of delayed action is evident when comparing India’s growth trajectory with that of countries like China. The next phase of India’s growth must prioritize foundational development — quality education at all levels, robust infrastructure, and logistics systems — to support sustainable and inclusive growth.
India’s story post-independence is filled with achievements but also missed opportunities. While we can celebrate our strides in higher education and IT, we must critically examine the gaps in primary education and infrastructure that continue to hinder growth. Moving forward, the focus must shift to inclusive policies that build human capital at every level and invest in infrastructure that fuels both economic and social mobility. Only then can India unlock its true potential and secure a future that is equitable, prosperous, and globally competitive.
Wednesday, March 19, 2025
Building Sustainable Agricultural Solutions: A Critical Look at Policy, Innovation, and Farmer Realities
Monday, March 17, 2025
A Three-Degree World: The Unequal Toll of Climate Change on Cities and Rural Areas
Saturday, March 15, 2025
Bridging the Financial Literacy Gap Among India’s Digital-First Youth
India vs China: A Tale of Two Startup Worlds
When it comes to the startup ecosystems of India and China, comparisons often lead to intriguing insights. Despite their geograp...
-
India's judicial system, though robust and well-structured, is often criticized for its inefficiency, mainly due to the slug...
-
Investing in public health systems is often seen as a dual-purpose strategy—aimed at improving societal well-being while also fo...
-
Jagriti is a unique and impactful initiative aimed at fostering entrepreneurship in India by providing a platform for budding an...