The Annual Survey of Micro, Small, and Medium Enterprises (MSMEs) in India aims to explore the potential of e-commerce platforms in enhancing market access and enabling the growth of MSMEs. It is widely believed that e-commerce platforms can provide new sales channels for MSMEs, allowing them to reach customers in a wider geographical market. However, limited evidence is available on the engagement of MSMEs with e-commerce platforms in India, as this information is often proprietary and not accessible to researchers. This report fills this knowledge gap by conducting a comprehensive primary survey of MSMEs, combining data from integrated and non-integrated enterprises to understand the potential of e-commerce in India.
The survey was conducted between 4 November 2022 and 20 January 2023, covering 2,007 MSMEs across different size categories. The majority of the firms in the sample were micro-sized (65%), followed by small-sized (19%) and medium-sized enterprises (16%). Out of the total sample, 50% of the enterprises were integrated with e-commerce platforms, while the remaining 50% were not. The survey spanned six product categories, including sports goods, toys, processed and preserved food products, apparel, furniture, and handicraft products. It covered several cities in India, such as Ahmedabad, Bhubaneshwar, Delhi, Jaipur, Lucknow, Ludhiana, Jalandhar, Agra, Meerut, Saharanpur, and Chennai. All the enterprises included in the sample were registered on the Udyam portal, a government facility that provides firms with a permanent registration and basic identification number.
The survey questionnaire aimed to gather information on key performance indicators of the firms, including sales, employment, and profitability. It also captured important characteristics of the businesses, such as export orientation and demographic factors of the owners. This allows for a comparative assessment of MSMEs engaged in e-commerce platforms and those that are not. The survey design also takes into account the heterogeneities within the MSME sector, recognizing that factors influencing e-commerce integration and performance may differ across micro, small, and medium enterprises.
Survey Findings
The survey findings shed light on the characteristics and performance of integrated and non-integrated MSMEs in India. The results indicate that firms with younger and more educated owners are more likely to integrate with e-commerce platforms. The survey also revealed that women-owned MSMEs are not far behind male-owned firms in terms of e-commerce integration, despite women's underrepresentation in the overall MSME landscape. Export-oriented firms were found to have a higher propensity for e-commerce integration, suggesting a positive relationship between export orientation and digitalization.
Integrated firms generally exhibited better performance compared to non-integrated firms. They reported higher turnovers, profitability, and a higher share of permanent employees in their workforce. Integration with e-commerce platforms brought several benefits, with a significant percentage of integrated enterprises reporting an increase in total sales and profit margins. Many firms also invested in employee training, new equipment, machinery, and software upon joining e-commerce platforms. Integration was associated with improvements in product design, adoption of new business practices, and organizational methods, indicating investment and innovation at the firm level.
While integrated firms saw several positive outcomes, the survey also identified challenges faced by non-integrated MSMEs. Lack of knowledge and information about digital technologies and e-commerce platforms emerged as key barriers to integration. Policymakers and stakeholders must take into account the potential inequities that may arise between integrated and non-integrated firms and work towards bridging the divide. Investments in technology, digital skills, infrastructure services, financial services, managerial and business skills, and enterprise support and training are crucial in enhancing the capabilities and productivity of MSMEs.
Key Challenges and Policy Recommendations
Based on the survey findings, the report highlights key challenges faced by MSMEs in India and provides policy recommendations to address these challenges. One of the main challenges is the lack of knowledge and information about e-commerce platforms, which hinders the integration of MSMEs. To overcome this barrier, the report suggests the need for awareness programs, capacity-building initiatives, and training programs to enhance digital literacy and provide information on the benefits and process of e-commerce integration.
Access to finance is another challenge for MSMEs, both integrated and non-integrated. The report recommends the development of innovative financing mechanisms, such as linking e-commerce platform sales to loan accounts or leveraging fintech companies and non-banking financial corporations for easier access to loans. It also emphasizes the importance of improving credit assessment processes and expanding the availability of formal finance to MSMEs, especially those without a presence on e-commerce platforms.
Infrastructure development is crucial for the growth of MSMEs and their integration with e-commerce platforms. The report suggests the provision of reliable and affordable internet connectivity, enhanced logistics and transportation networks, and access to electricity and other utilities. Improving physical infrastructure will facilitate smoother online transactions, reduce costs, and enhance the overall competitiveness of MSMEs.
The report also highlights the need for collaborative efforts between government bodies, industry associations, e-commerce companies, and other stakeholders. Policy coordination and dialogue are essential to create an enabling environment for MSMEs to integrate with e-commerce platforms. Cooperation between different stakeholders can lead to the development of supportive regulations, policies, and initiatives that promote MSME growth and facilitate e-commerce integration.
Conclusions
The Annual Survey of MSMEs in India sheds light on the potential of e-commerce platforms in enhancing market access and enabling the growth of MSMEs. The survey findings indicate that integration with e-commerce platforms brings significant benefits to MSMEs, including improved market access, increased sales and profit margins, investment in technology and innovation, and access to formal finance. However, challenges remain, particularly for non-integrated MSMEs, who face barriers such as lack of knowledge and information. Bridging the gap between integrated and non-integrated firms requires investments in digital skills, infrastructure development, and enterprise support. Policy coordination and collaboration among various stakeholders are crucial in creating an enabling environment for MSMEs to leverage e-commerce platforms for their growth.
The report concludes by emphasizing the importance of leveraging the potential of e-commerce platforms to foster inclusive and sustainable growth for MSMEs in India. E-commerce integration can help overcome the limitations of local markets and enable MSMEs to reach a wider customer base, both domestically and internationally. By addressing the challenges and implementing the recommended policy measures, India can unlock the full potential of its MSME sector, contributing to economic development, job creation, and poverty alleviation.
https://drive.google.com/file/d/1QCFrrbBPhf0O4X1asGwC2bxzqX69GWw4/view?usp=drivesdk
